OPEN JOURNAL
T
The One That Got Away
5 STORIES

The One That Got Away

@theonethatgotaway
5 Stories

Unfiltered stories of past relationships, avoidant mistakes, the texts left unsaid, and the love that slipped through our fingers.

T
The One That Got Away
Regretful
Gulberg, Lahore
Soundtrack cover
Soundtrack Deezer

I Was the Avoidant: What I Wish I'd Known Earlier

Her last WhatsApp note sat on read for three days. The ceiling fan clicked through the humid Lahore night, and I watched the blue tick turn grey under my thumb. I had nothing to say—not because I didn't care, but because caring meant admitting I had already pulled the pin on the grenade. We met at a friend's dholki, her dupatta slipping off one shoulder as she laughed at my terrible Punjabi. I knew within a week that she saw a future I couldn't even hold in my hands. She'd send me voice notes about her mother's dal recipe, about a stray kitten near her university gate. I'd reply with a single 'Haha' or a thumbs-up emoji. She never complained, but I saw the hope dim in her eyes every time I chose distance over presence. The avoidant doesn't feel like a monster. He feels like a man drowning, and pushing her away is the only way to keep her from going under with him. I told myself I was protecting her from my mess—my father's unspoken expectations, my own fear of being seen completely. But protection was just a beautiful lie I wrapped around my cowardice. She called me on a Thursday evening, her voice steady but thin. 'Can we talk about us?' I was at a roadside chai stall, the steam fogging my glasses. I said, 'There's nothing to talk about.' That was the moment. She didn't cry. She said, 'Okay, Anwar. Take care.' And hung up. I sat there till the chai turned cold, watching a stray dog limp past the streetlights. Three months later, my mother handed me her phone, eyebrows raised. 'She's engaged. Didn't you know?' The screen showed a wedding card on Facebook—her smiling in a red dupatta, a man I'd never seen beside her. I zoomed in on her face, looking for signs of sadness. There were none. She had already grieved and moved on while I was still stuck in the room I'd locked her out of. The avoidant doesn't get to feel betrayed. She asked for breadcrumbs, and I gave her silence. I rehearsed apologies in my head during sleepless nights, but never typed them. I imagined running into her at Liberty Market, saying something profound. But life doesn't write Bollywood scenes for people who let love slip through their fingers like sand. What I wish I'd known: avoidant isn't a personality—it's a decision made in small, reversible moments. You choose to send the emoji instead of the voice note. You choose to say 'fine' instead of 'I'm scared.' You choose to let her last message sit unread until the blue tick becomes a tombstone. And then one day you realize you're not protecting anyone; you're just building a prison of your own quiet, and she's already the one who got away. Tonight, the ceiling fan still clicks, the tea is cold, and I still have her number saved under a name I can't delete. The ache isn't loud. It's a low hum, like a prayer I never learned to finish.

T
The One That Got Away
Disillusioned
My apartment in Gulberg, Lahore

He Got Engaged a Month After We Broke Up

The news came through a mutual friend’s Instagram story. I was scrolling in bed at 1am, phone on 12% battery, and there it was. A photo of him in a dark blue shalwar kameez, a red sehra around his neck, and her beside him in a champagne lehnga. Her name was posted in the caption with a heart emoji. I didn’t know her. I didn’t even know he was seeing anyone. The engagement had happened in Karachi the previous weekend, and I was finding out through a blurry screenshot on a girl I barely talk to. I put the phone down and stared at the ceiling fan. It was the same fan that clicked forty times per minute, the same one that spun above me the night he sent that last voice note. He said, “I think we need a break” in a tone that was too rehearsed. I had agreed because I was tired of begging for crumbs. That was five months ago. A month after that call, he was engaged. The timeline doesn’t lie. He must have met her within weeks of our breakup, or maybe before. I don’t know which version hurts more. I texted my sister in the morning. “Did you know?” She said she had heard something but didn’t want to tell me. She asked if I was okay. I said I was fine, which is a lie I tell so often it has become muscle memory. I wasn’t fine. I was sitting on the edge of my bed, the quilt twisted around my legs, drinking chai that had gone cold because I forgot to drink it. The milk had formed a thin skin on top. I stared at it for a long time. The worst part is not the engagement itself. It is the way he did it. No message to me. No warning. Just a story on someone else’s phone. He owed me nothing, I know that. I ended things? Actually, he ended it. No, I was the avoidant? In the previous journal I wrote about being the avoidant, but that was about a different person, a different grief. This is a new wound. I was the one who pulled the pin in that earlier relationship. But with him, I was the one left holding the grenade. Or maybe I was the grenade. I pushed him away with my silence, my need for space, my inability to say “I need you”. And he found someone who could say it easily. I remember the last time we fought. It was over something stupid. I said I didn’t like his friend’s comments about my career. He said I was being oversensitive. I walked out of the coffee shop and didn’t look back. He called three times. I let it ring. The fourth time I answered and said, “I think we need to stop.” He was quiet for ten seconds. Then he said, “If that’s what you want.” I didn’t want it. I wanted him to fight. But I had trained him not to fight because I always left. So he let me go. And a month later he got engaged. My mother called at noon. She didn’t know about him. She was talking about rishtas, about a boy from the bank who was “settled”. I listened with the phone wedged between my ear and shoulder while I washed the same cup three times. She said, “Beta, you are not getting younger.” I said, “Amma, I am only twenty seven.” She said, “That is exactly what I mean.” I hung up and sat on the kitchen floor. The tiles were cold. The refrigerator hummed. I thought about the engagement photo again. The seam of his kurta collar was slightly crooked. He always buttoned his kurta wrong. I used to fix it for him. Now someone else will fix it. I opened our old WhatsApp chat. It was archived. I unarchived it and scrolled to the last message from him. It was a voice note from five months ago. I didn’t play it. I just looked at the waveform on the screen. The date was there. I did the math. Five months and one week. He got engaged exactly thirty two days after we ended. I don’t know why I needed to know the exact number. It feels like a score. He beat me to moving on. Or maybe he was already moving while I was still packing. The worst thought is this. He probably didn’t even think of me when he put the ring on her finger. He was happy. The photo showed a genuine smile, the kind he only gave when he forgot to perform. I knew that smile. I made it happen once or twice. But now it belongs to someone else’s camera roll. I wonder if he told her about me. Probably not. Men like him don’t mention the past when the future is shiny. I am a deleted history. A note he archived and never opened again. I closed the chat and didn’t archive it this time. I left it in my main inbox. It sits there now, a grey icon with his old display picture, a photo of him at a beach in Hawksbay. The water was blue. He was squinting into the sun. I took that photo. I remember him complaining about the sand in his shoes. I laughed and said it was romantic. He said sand was never romantic. I think about that now and I realize he was always practical. He would never wait around for someone who ran away. He would just find a girl who stayed. My phone buzzed. It was my sister again, asking if I wanted to go out for dinner. I said maybe. I haven’t replied yet. It is 3pm and the light is slanted through the window, falling across the engagement photo still open on my laptop. I closed it. But the thumbnail stays in my recent files. I don’t have the energy to delete it. I will probably stare at it again tonight. Tomorrow I will tell my mother I am ready to meet the bank boy. Not because I want to. But because sitting here with a cold cup of chai and a ghost of a smile is starting to feel like a punishment I don’t deserve.

T
The One That Got Away
Regretful
My bedroom in Gulberg, Lahore, 2:17 AM

The Last Text I Never Sent

I have the draft saved in my notes app. Not even in WhatsApp, because I know if I type it there it will tempt me with the blue send button. It is a note called “never sending this” and it has been sitting there for nine days now. The cursor blinks at the end of the third sentence like it knows I am a coward. The text says: “I saw the photos. I hope you are happy. I should have said this before you left but I am sorry for the way I ended things. I was scared and I took it out on you.” That is where I stopped. I could not write more. The truth is I do not know what I would even want him to say back. The chai on my nightstand has a thick brown film on top. I brewed it at midnight because sleep felt like a performance I was failing. The microwave clock says 2:18 but I think it is nine minutes fast. I have not fixed it because that feels like admitting I care about time. My phone is on 7% battery and I keep plugging it in and unplugging it. The charging cable is frayed near the tip and sometimes the connection flickers. That flickering feels appropriate right now. His engagement was three weeks ago. I know because the mutual friend posted a second story with a cake cutting. The date is burned into my brain like a scar I keep picking at. May 11th. A Saturday. I was at home in my old kurti with a stain on the collar from lunch. I watched the story three times in a row. Her face is round and soft. She looks like the kind of girl who laughs easily, who does not overthink a single text for nine days. I envied her for that before I even knew her name. I still do. I keep replaying the last conversation we had. It was on the phone, a Tuesday night, both of us lying in our separate beds. He said something about his mother asking when we would finalise the rishta and I felt my chest tighten. I told him I needed space. He said okay. He did not fight. He never fought. That was the problem. I wanted him to yell or cry or something. Instead he just said “take as much time as you need” and then he sent me a picture of the moon. I never replied to that picture. I think about that moon photo a lot. It was blurry because his hands shake when he holds his phone up. I knew that about him. I knew the way his hands shake and I still did not reply. My parents think I am over it. My mother asked yesterday if I wanted her to “look into a few proposals” and I said sure just to shut her up. She smiled and said “that’s my girl” like I had done something brave. I have not done anything brave. I have been sitting in this room for three nights straight eating leftover biryani from the fridge and watching the same episode of a show I do not even like. The fan makes a clicking noise every time it rotates past the light fixture. I used to tell him about that clicking noise and he said he would come fix it one day. He never did. I never asked him to. The unsent text has changed twice since I wrote it. I deleted the line about being scared because it sounded like an excuse. I added a question asking if he hated me now. Then I deleted that too because I do not think I could handle the answer. The current version just says “I hope you are happy” and then a period. That is it. Seven words. I have edited seven words for over a week. It is pathetic. I know it is pathetic. But I cannot press send because once I do I lose the right to pretend I am fine. As long as that draft sits there I can tell myself I am still in control. That I am choosing not to reach out. That is a lie. I am terrified of what his reply would say. What if it is cold? What if it is kind? Kind would be worse. Kind would mean he has moved on fully and can afford to be gracious. I do not want his grace. I want him to tell me I broke his heart. I want the guilt to feel earned. There is a photo of us stuck in the edge of my mirror. It is from a trip to Murree last winter. He is wearing that mustard sweater I hated and I am laughing at something off camera. I keep it there because taking it down would feel like admitting defeat. But every time I look at it I see the way his arm is around my shoulder. Casual. Like I belonged there. I do not belong in that photo anymore. I do not belong in his life. He has a wife now. She gets his mornings. She gets to see his hands shake when he is nervous. I wonder if she knows he does that. I wonder if he told her about me. Probably not. Men like him do not bring up the ex who ghosted after the moon photo. The rain started ten minutes ago. Light at first, then heavier. It sounds like someone shaking a tin roof. My window is open a crack and the curtain moves a little. I smell wet earth and diesel from the road. I used to love the rain. Now it just makes me think of the time we got stuck in it on his bike and he covered my head with his jacket. We were both soaked and shivering and he laughed the whole time. That was two years ago. Two years and three months. I remember because it was the first week after we met. I still have that jacket. It is in the back of my closet under a pile of old dupattas. I have never given it back. He never asked for it. That is the thing about us. Neither of us ever asked for what we really wanted. My phone just buzzed. It was a notification from the weather app. Thunderstorm warning until 4 AM. I unlocked the phone and stared at the unsent note again. The cursor is still blinking. I typed one more word just now. “Really.” I wrote: “I hope you are happy. Really.” And then I locked the screen. That is the closest I will get. I think about him reading it and his hands shaking and the photo of the moon. I think about her in the champagne lehnga. I think about the rain outside and the clicking fan and the chai I will never finish. I do not think I will ever send it. That is probably for the best. But I wish it did not feel this much like giving up.

T
The One That Got Away
Regretful
My bedroom, Kota Kinabalu, across from the window where the streetlight flickers

Six Years Together, and Our Families Never Knew

The streetlight outside my window has been flickering for three weeks now. I told myself I would report it to the city council but I never did. It blinks every seven seconds like a heartbeat that cannot decide whether to stop. I am sitting on the edge of my bed with my phone face down on the mattress. The screen is dark but I know exactly what is underneath it. A draft message in my notes app called “never sending this.” It has been there for sixteen days now. Sixteen days since I saw the engagement photos on her cousin's Instagram. Sixteen days since I last cried in the bathroom at work and told my colleague it was allergies. Her name is Alia. We were together for six years. Six years and our families never knew. Not even a hint. I never met her mother. She never met my father. We were ghosts in each other's lives. We planned it that way because we were both too afraid to explain what we had. Her parents wanted her to marry a Malay guy from a good family, someone with a government pension and a house in the suburbs. I am Chinese, I run a small printing shop that barely breaks even, and I smoke too much. We knew from the start that our families would never accept it. So we hid. We hid so well that sometimes I wonder if we even believed ourselves. I remember the first time she stayed over at my rented room in Luyang. She brought a toothbrush and a change of clothes in a plastic bag from Giant. She said “my mom thinks I am sleeping over at Sara's place.” I laughed and said “my dad thinks I am working late.” We both knew that lie would only work for so long but we kept telling it anyway. Six years of Sara's place. Six years of working late. Six years of secret WhatsApp chats with the notification preview turned off so no one would accidentally see her name on my lock screen. Her name still shows up as “Sara” in my contacts because I never changed it after the first year. I do not have the heart to delete it. The worst part is that I was the one who pulled the pin on the grenade. I ended it. Not because I stopped loving her but because I got tired. Tired of lying to my father when he asked why I was not seeing anyone. Tired of watching her flinch every time her phone buzzed during family dinners. Tired of being a secret that felt more like a shame than a safety. I told her I could not do it anymore. I said the words “I think we should stop” while we were sitting in my car outside a 7-Eleven in Penampang. She did not scream. She just nodded and got out of the car and walked into the store and bought a bottle of water. She did not cry until she got back in and then she cried so quietly I could barely hear it over the engine. I did not cry at all. I drove her home and said nothing. That was seven months ago. Seven months and now she is engaged to a man named Azhar. I do not know him. I only know he works in finance and his family is from Kuching and he proposed at a beach resort in Semporna. I know all of this because I checked her cousin's Instagram at two in the morning last week when I could not sleep. The photos are glossy and posed. She is wearing a gold dress and her hair is pinned up with flowers. She looks beautiful. She looks like someone I do not recognize. The caption says “final proposal yay!” with a ring emoji. I stared at that photo for so long my phone battery dropped from forty percent to fifteen before I noticed. Then I opened my notes app and started typing the draft that I will never send. I told myself I would not check again but I did tonight. Her cousin posted a story of the engagement party. A short video clip of Alia laughing with her hand over her mouth. Azhar is beside her with his arm around her waist. In the video she looks at him the way she used to look at me when I made her laugh in the car. The same crinkle at the corner of her eyes. The same tilt of her head. I watched it three times. Then I turned off my phone and put it face down and now I am sitting here staring at the flickering streetlight. The truth is I do not know if I regret ending it or if I just regret how I ended it. I could have said more. I could have explained that I was scared not just of our families but of what would happen if we kept hiding for another six years. I could have told her that I loved her enough to let her go find someone she did not have to lie about. But I did not say any of that. I just said I think we should stop and then I watched her buy a bottle of water. That is the version of me that lives in her memory now. The guy who ended six years with a sentence in a car outside a convenience store. I do not get to rewrite that. My father texted me earlier tonight to ask if I had eaten dinner. I said yes even though I had not. He sends that text almost every night now. He is getting older and I think he worries that I am alone. I am alone. But I am not going to tell him that. I am not going to tell him about Alia or Azhar or the six years that never happened. Some secrets just stay secrets until they rot inside you. I think that is what I am feeling right now. Rot. Not the dramatic kind that makes you cry in public. The quiet kind that sits in your chest while you watch a streetlight blink on and off and on and off. Tomorrow I will wake up and I will go to the printing shop and I will tell customers that their banner orders will be ready by Friday. I will smile and make small talk and pretend that my entire emotional life is not a locked room inside my own head. And tonight I will not send the draft. I will leave it in my notes app with the cursor blinking at the end of the third sentence. The cursor that knows I am a coward. The cursor that never blinks as fast as the streetlight outside my window. It is 1:47 AM now. My phone battery is at twenty-three percent. I should plug it in but I will not. I will let it drain until the screen goes black and then I will try to sleep.

T
The One That Got Away
Resigned
My bedroom, the same flickering streetlight outside

I Still Check Her Profile on Her Birthday

The streetlight is still flickering. I never reported it. It blinks every seven seconds just like it did three months ago when I wrote that draft message I never sent. Tonight is her birthday. I know because my phone buzzed with a Google reminder at 9 AM. I deleted the notification but the number stuck in my head. 26. She turned 26 today. I sat on the edge of my bed at 11 PM and opened Instagram without thinking. My thumb went straight to the search bar. Her name autofilled before I could type a single letter. Her profile picture is new. A photo of her in a blue kurta I do not recognize, smiling next to a man I have never seen. His arm is around her shoulder. The caption says “my person” with a red heart. I stared at it for maybe two minutes. The phone battery was at 34 percent. I did not scroll further. I just looked at that one image and then locked the screen. The room went black except for the streetlight through the curtains. I remember her birthday last year. We spent it in a small cafe in Bandra. She ordered a slice of red velvet cake and I stole half of it. She laughed and said “you always do this” and I said “because you always let me.” She was wearing a yellow dress. I had bought her a small silver ring from a street vendor. She wore it on her middle finger. I do not know if she still has it. I do not know if she ever took it off after I ended things. I ended things over a phone call. That is the part I hate most about myself. Six years together and I could not look her in the eye. I called her on a Tuesday evening. I said “I think we need to stop.” She said “stop what” and I said “this” and then there was a long silence. I could hear her breathing. She asked if there was someone else. I said no. She asked if I was sure. I said yes. She said “okay” and hung up. That was it. No fight. No crying. Just a click and a dial tone. I sat in my car for an hour with the engine off. Our families never knew. That was the rule we made when we started. Both our parents were already discussing arranged matches by the time we were 23. We thought we had time. We thought we would eventually tell them after we both had jobs, after we were stable. But six years passed and we never did. I kept saying “next year” and she kept nodding. I was the one who could not cross that line. I was the one who pulled the pin on the grenade and then walked away before it exploded. The explosion came later. It came in the form of a silent phone. It came in the form of her blocking me on WhatsApp three days after the call. Now she is with someone new. Or maybe that man is the one her family arranged. The blue kurta she wore looks like something a mother would pick out for an engagement ceremony. I do not know for sure. I only know that I still check her profile on her birthday. I do it every year. This is the second one since we ended. Last year her profile was just a picture of a flower. This year it is a picture of him. Next year it might be a wedding photo. I will still check. I will sit in this same spot on this same bed and let my thumb move without permission. I wonder if she checks mine. Probably not. I have not posted anything in eight months. My profile is a blank square with a default icon. I do not want to know if she looks. I want her to forget me. I also want her to remember me forever. Both things are true and they cancel each other out. That is what I am left with. A contradiction that sits in my chest like a stone I cannot swallow. My mother called me earlier today. She asked if I had heard about Priya’s engagement. Priya is a cousin. I said no. She said “she is marrying a boy from Surat. Very nice family.” I said “good for her.” My mother paused and then said “beta, when are you going to settle down?” I said “soon” and changed the subject. She does not know about the girl who wore a yellow dress and ate red velvet cake in Bandra. She does not know that I already settled down once and then burned it all down with my own hands. It is almost midnight now. The streetlight is still flickering. I have not moved from the edge of the bed. My phone is face down on the mattress again. The draft message is still in my notes. It starts with “I am sorry” and ends with “I hope you are happy.” I have never sent it. I will not send it tonight either. But I will keep it there. Like the profile checks. Like the flickering bulb. Like everything I cannot bring myself to fix or let go.

✦
The One That Got Away
ALL CAUGHT UP

You're all caught up

You've reached the end of this journal for now.

Album artwork

Song Title

Artist Name

Music provided by Deezer